Legal Challenge to DFO's Herring Fishery Management
Dear Minister Thompson,
The attached letter to you is part of a long-standing effort to bring DFO’s mismanagement of the Pacific herring fishery to the Minister’s attention, and to achieve a pause in harvesting in both the winter and spring fisheries, so the dangerously declining herring stocks can recover on our coast.
We have discussed our concerns with MPs Elizabeth May and Gord Johns, who have both recently met with you on this issue. We hope to share our views with MP Patrick Weiler, Chair of FOPO and MP Earnie Klassen, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans.
The W̱SÁNEĆ Hereditary Chiefs, led by WIĆKINEM (Eric Pelkey) hereditary chief of the Tsawout Nation, are seeking a legal opinion from John Rich of Ratcliff LLP, on a breach to their Douglas Treaty rights. Many ENGO organizations are currently supporting this initiative, including ourselves, the Herring Conservation and Restoration Society (HCRS). This follows the W̱SÁNEĆ Hereditary Chiefs’ 2024 Herring Declaration calling for a moratorium of the commercial herring fishery. We are in discussion with other First Nations who may also publicly share their positions on protecting the herring stocks.
The W̱SÁNEĆ Hereditary Chiefs, together with the HCRS, have organized the last two HELIT TŦE SȽOṈ,ET (Let the Herring Live) forums, bringing together First Nations, fishery scientists, health professionals and ENGOs, and joins Conservancy Hornby Island’s annual HerringFest, to focus attention on protecting the herring and the marine ecosystem they sustain.
We hope you will give the attached letter, with its background references, your full attention and look forward to discussing our concerns with you and your colleagues.
Sincerely,
Dorrance Woodward
Herring Conservation Restoration Society
https://savetheherring.org/
For further information contact:
Chief Eric Pelkey, hereditary chief of the Tsawout Nation and a member of the WSANEC hereditary chiefs, HCRS director, eric.pelkey@wsanec.com
Dr. Briony Penn, Treasurer HCRS, info@savetheherring.org
To read the full 4-page letter including research citations, please click below:
ADIMS 2025 Annual General Meeting
Notice of Annual General Meeting
Tuesday, Nov 25, 2025, 4:00 PM
ADIMS members, donors, and the general public are welcome to join us via Zoom on your computer or smart phone:
— LINK will be published shortly —
Meeting ID: TBD | Passcode: TBD
For connecting via landline, dial by your location:
+1 778 907 2071 Canada
Find your local number: https://us06web.zoom.us/u/klrO7lDTG
ADIMS provides the residents of Denman Island a strong voice in protecting our marine environment.
For more info: www.adims.ca | Email: adimsinfo@gmail.com | Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/AssociationforDenmanIslandMarineStewards/
One for ADIMS: Goodbye Shellfish Predator Netting in Estuaries
ADIMS would like to thank Tony Gregson for his excellent article in the September 12th issue of The Barnacle, where he correctly states that:
"Under the 2025 iteration of the Conditions of Licence for shellfish tenures in Baynes Sound, DFO (Department of Fisheries and Oceans) requires that anti-predator netting must be removed by 2027 from the estuaries of the creeks and rivers that enter the Sound. Specifically, there can be no netting within 50 meters on either side of estuary streamlets. As streamlets braid out over the entire area of an estuary, that effectively excludes any netting. Licensees must also remove the channels."
We were elated to hear about these changes in DFO's 2025 Conditions of Licence, as ADIMS has been advocating for the removal of predator netting from estuaries for many years.
Click below to read Tony's 1.5 page article where he goes into greater depth on the issue:
Suspend the Strait of Georgia Herring Fisheries
Dear the Integrated Herring Harvest Planning Committee (IHHPC),
The following comments are submitted jointly by Pacific Wild Alliance, Conservancy Hornby Island, Herring Conservation and Research Society, Saanich Inlet Protection Society, Bowen Island Conservancy, Association for Denman Island Marine Stewards, Friends of Shoal Harbour, BC Nature, Rocky Point Bird Observatory, Friends of
Victoria Harbour Migratory Bird Sanctuary, and Nature Victoria in response to the 2024/2025 Integrated Fishery Management Plan (IFMP) for Pacific herring. We stand in solidarity with the WSANEC hereditary chiefs and also make reference to supporting the Q’ul-lhanumutsun Aquatic Resources Society banning the Food and Bait in
their territories (Cowichan Tribes, Halalt First Nation, Lyackson First Nation, Penelakut Tribe, Stz'uminus First Nation, and Ts'uubaa-asatx Nations).
Pacific herring are the foundation of the coastal food web in British Columbia (B.C.) and urgently need protection. We, the undersigned, advocate for a swift transition to an ecosystem approach to fisheries management of Pacific herring, alongside an immediate suspension of the commercial herring fishery in the Strait of Georgia (SoG) to allow the population to recover to historical abundance.
To read the full joint feedback document with our recommendations and scientific references, click here:
Joint Feedback on the 2024_2025 Herring Integrated Fisheries Management Plan
Voice your concern about Intertidal Geoduck in Baynes Sound!
Sign our Parliamentary Petition!
ADIMS has started an e-petition, which asks the government to postpone any further shellfish aquaculture expansion into herring spawning and rearing habitat and to develop a co-management plan with First Nations in Baynes Sound/Lambert Channel.
We need at least 500 signatures to have the petition presented to the House of Commons by MP Gord Johns. After a petition is presented, the government must respond within 45 days. We hope to have many petition signatures to show support for our concerns about the long-term impacts of this industry on herring.
Here is a link to the e-petition:
https://petitions.ourcommons.ca/en/Petition/Details?Petition=e-3965
Call for a Moratorium on the Herring Fishery, Dorrie Woodward
Dorrie Woodward for Assn for Denman Island Marine Stewards
Thank you Denise McKean for organizing this letter writing effort!
In early March, Denman and Hornby Islands will be at the centre of a marvellous marine Serengeti.
The Georgia Strait herring stock will be spawning around our islands and thousands of sea birds, seals, eagles, salmon, sea lions, and even whales will gather to feast on herring before they themselves go on to reproduce and raise their young later in spring.
Baynes Sound is a precious herring rearing ground for hatchlings and Lambert Channel is one of the most important, consistently used spawning grounds ever recorded on the Pacific coast. Priceless.
This herring stock gives food security to thousands of marine creatures, including marine birds, as well as to many First Nations communities for thousands of years in the past.
It is also the last commercially harvest-able stock in BC. Once there were five major and two minor herring stocks which were commercially harvested, but no more. Fisheries and Oceans Canada, DFO, which manages this fishery, has used the same management regime since 1983, which on paper seems conservative and precautionary but in practice has resulted in immense harm. Herring stocks have dwindled and not recovered with tragic consequences for the wild and human populations which rely on their flesh and eggs.
DFO says that this Georgia Strait stock is in good shape, and plans to open the fishery for commercial harvest, and to allow the industry to take 20% of the estimated biomass. This is their conservative approach/chronic mismanagement that got us down to one remaining stock.
This is why the First Nations on the West Coast of Vancouver Island, Central Coast, North Coast and on Haida Gwaii have taken legal steps to stop DFO and protect what’s left of their herring stocks. This is why ADIMS and other groups including Hornby Conservancy and Pacific Wild have joined the WSANEC Tribal Leadership Council in calling for a Moratorium on the Georgia Strait herring fishery.
In an ocean struggling with climate change, and with the catastrophic loss of herring stocks,we are demanding DFO put a Moratorium in place. Fishers must be fairly compensated, however the risk of stock collapse is too high to maintain business as usual.
Add your voice to ours and write DFO Minister Bernadette Jordan on behalf of the herring. Let the Herring Live!
For more information:
https://pacificwild.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Top-Ten-Arguments-against-the-Strait-of-Georgia-herring-fishery.pdf
https://pacificwild.org/biglittlefish/
https://www.conservancyhornbyisland.org/